One bite, and you’re done for.
Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop on Elizabeth Street doesn’t just serve dessert — it serves obsession. The first forkful hits with that sharp citrus snap, then melts into silky sweetness that lingers long after the plate is clean.
It’s bright, bold, and unapologetically Florida.
Step inside and the scent alone will test your willpower. Tangy lime hangs in the air.
Chocolate-dipped slices tempt you from the counter. Whipped cream crowns each pie like it knows it’s about to steal the show.
You tell yourself you’ll share. You won’t.
Locals swear by it. Travelers detour for it.
Some even pack whole pies for the flight home, guarding the box like treasure.
This isn’t just a slice of pie. It’s the taste that sneaks into your thoughts months later, calling you back to the Keys for just one more bite.
The Classic Key Lime Pie Slice
There’s a reason people plan their entire Key West trip around one slice of pie. At Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop, the classic key lime pie slice is the star of the show.
It’s priced at just under $6, which feels exactly right for something this well-crafted.
The filling is the real magic here. Reviewers consistently describe it as creamy, refreshing, and not overly sweet — hitting that ideal spot between tangy and rich.
The graham cracker crust gives each bite a satisfying crunch that holds everything together beautifully.
If you only have time for one thing at Kermit’s, the classic slice is where to start. It’s the benchmark by which every other key lime pie gets measured, and it sets the bar impressively high.
Key Lime Pie on a Stick Dipped in Chocolate
Whoever thought to put key lime pie on a stick and dip it in chocolate deserves serious credit. Kermit’s took a beloved classic and turned it into something you can walk around Key West enjoying, no fork required.
It’s playful, portable, and frankly one of the most satisfying ways to experience the shop’s signature flavor.
The frozen version locks in that creamy, tangy filling at a cool temperature, making it especially refreshing on a hot Florida afternoon. The chocolate shell adds a layer of richness that plays surprisingly well against the tartness of the lime.
It’s the kind of combination that sounds odd on paper but tastes completely natural in practice.
If you’re strolling Duval Street or heading back toward the cruise terminal, grab one of these for the walk. It travels well, melts slowly enough to enjoy, and makes for a genuinely fun Florida memory.
Coconut Key Lime Pie Variation
Not everyone arrives at Kermit’s as a citrus devotee, and the shop seems to know that. The coconut key lime pie is a brilliant variation that softens the tartness of traditional key lime with the mellow sweetness of coconut.
One reviewer’s boyfriend — a self-described non-fan of citrus — tried the coconut version and called it yummy and refreshing.
The coconut adds a tropical depth to the already vibrant lime flavor, making each bite feel like a mini vacation. Toasted coconut flakes on top give it a lovely texture contrast, and the overall effect is creamy, smooth, and deeply satisfying.
It’s familiar enough to be comforting but interesting enough to feel like a real find.
Several visitors who spotted this flavor in the dessert case mentioned wanting to try it on a return visit, suggesting it has serious staying power in the memory department. That’s the mark of a truly great flavor variation — it lingers in your mind long after you’ve left the shop.
For anyone who finds pure key lime a little too tart, the coconut version is the perfect bridge. It’s approachable, crowd-pleasing, and genuinely delicious in its own right, not just a compromise.
Key Lime Pie Cheesecake
Imagine the tangy brightness of key lime pie meeting the dense, velvety richness of a New York-style cheesecake. That’s exactly what Kermit’s key lime pie cheesecake delivers, and it’s earned some of the most enthusiastic praise of anything on the menu.
One reviewer called it “one of the best desserts I have ever had” — a statement that carries real weight when you consider how many desserts get tried on a Key West vacation.
Pairing this with a seat in the outdoor courtyard and some Florida sunshine makes for an experience that’s hard to top. The shop’s charming decor and welcoming staff only add to the overall feeling of being somewhere genuinely special.
If you’re the kind of person who can never choose between cheesecake and pie, Kermit’s has done the decision-making for you. Order a slice and prepare to have a new favorite dessert.
Free Sample Culture and Tasting Experience
Walking into Kermit’s feels less like entering a bakery and more like being welcomed into someone’s home. Samples are set out all around the store — cookies, lime-flavored treats, and little bites of this and that — inviting you to taste freely before committing to a purchase.
It’s a wonderfully generous approach that immediately puts visitors at ease and makes the whole experience feel fun rather than transactional.
Reviewers consistently mention the samples as one of their favorite parts of the visit. The try-before-you-buy setup means you can explore flavors you might never have considered ordering on your own.
More than one person has discovered their new favorite treat — like those legendary white chocolate chip cookies — entirely through a sample they weren’t expecting to love.
The staff adds to this atmosphere in a big way. Employees like Vasyl and Diego have been singled out by name in reviews for their patient, enthusiastic guidance through the menu.
They explain textures, flavor profiles, and preparation methods with the kind of care that makes a first-time visitor feel like a regular.
Even on busy days, the shop maintains a welcoming energy that keeps people coming back year after year. One family returned after ten years and found the same warmth they remembered — that says everything about what makes Kermit’s special.
The Outdoor Courtyard Seating Area
There’s something deeply satisfying about eating key lime pie outside in Key West, with warm Florida air and the relaxed energy of the island all around you. Kermit’s outdoor courtyard makes that experience even better.
Tucked to the side and back of the shop, the seating area is shaded, clean, and decorated with the same cheerful charm as the interior — a lovely spot to slow down and actually savor your treats.
Multiple reviewers have called the outdoor area beautiful and impressive, with one visitor specifically noting how lovingly the entire shop is furnished. The courtyard invites you to linger rather than rush, which feels exactly right for a vacation dessert stop.
Tables fill up quickly on busy afternoons, so grabbing a seat early is a smart move.
Dogs are welcome in the spirit of the place too — one reviewer mentioned that the shop even had a little snack available for their dog, which earned major bonus points for thoughtfulness. It’s the kind of detail that shows how much the team at Kermit’s thinks about the full visitor experience.
Whether you’re with family, a partner, or flying solo, settling into the courtyard with a slice of pie feels like the ideal Key West afternoon. Unhurried, sunny, and completely satisfying.
Key Lime Themed Gifts and Souvenirs
Kermit’s isn’t just a place to eat — it’s a place to shop for a little piece of Key West to take home. The store is stocked with a wide range of lime-themed gifts, from packaged cookies and nuts to specialty items that make perfect souvenirs.
Whether you’re shopping for yourself or picking up something for people back home, there’s genuinely something here for everyone.
Reviewers have mentioned grabbing multiple items to bring back as gifts, including cookies, rum cake, and various lime-flavored treats. The packaging is cute and travel-friendly, which matters when you’re trying to fit souvenirs into a carry-on.
A bag of those famous white chocolate chip key lime cookies, for example, makes a thoughtful and delicious gift that tells a real story about where you’ve been.
The gift selection also means that even visitors who aren’t huge dessert fans can find something to enjoy or bring back. Lime-themed items feel authentically Floridian rather than generic tourist trap merchandise, which makes them worth picking up.
One reviewer who visited with her boyfriend grabbed several souvenir items on their last day before leaving Key West, calling it a great final stop on their trip. That kind of sendoff — sweet, memorable, and uniquely local — is exactly what a great souvenir shop should provide.
Strawberry Key Lime Pie Flavor
Fruit forward and eye-catching, the strawberry key lime pie at Kermit’s is the kind of flavor variation that makes you stop mid-scroll through the dessert case and say, “Wait, what’s that one?” It brings a fruity sweetness to the classic key lime base, creating a combination that feels fresh and a little unexpected — in the best possible way.
A reviewer mentioned that her teenager spotted the strawberry option and loved every bite. That kind of cross-generational appeal is a good sign for any dessert.
It’s sweet enough for those who find plain key lime a touch too tart, while still carrying that unmistakable citrus backbone that makes key lime pie so distinctive.
The color alone makes it stand out in the display case, with a blush-pink hue that looks almost too pretty to eat. Almost.
One glance at the golden crust and creamy filling is usually enough to make the decision for you.
Kermit’s rotating cast of pie flavors — from classic to coconut to strawberry — ensures that repeat visitors always have something new to try. If you’ve already worked your way through the traditional options, the strawberry variation is a worthy next chapter in your Kermit’s pie journey.
It’s fun, flavorful, and very hard to share.
Key Lime Limeade and Refreshing Drinks
On a hot Key West afternoon, few things hit quite as well as a cold, freshly made limeade. Kermit’s serves one that reviewers have described as genuinely refreshing — tart, bright, and perfectly suited for sipping on a walk back to the hotel or along the waterfront.
It’s the kind of drink that makes Florida feel like exactly the right place to be.
One visitor grabbed a limeade for the walk back to her hotel just two minutes away and couldn’t stop raving about it alongside the coconut key lime pie she’d bought. The drink pairs naturally with everything else on the menu, cutting through the richness of pie or cheesecake with its clean citrus punch.
For families with kids or anyone who wants something to sip while browsing the gift section, the limeade is a practical and delicious choice. It’s easy to carry, refreshing in the heat, and gives you an extra taste of that key lime flavor the shop does so well.
Kermit’s has a way of turning every single item — whether it’s a full pie, a cookie, or just a drink — into a memorable part of the Key West experience. The limeade is no exception.
Small detail, big impression, and a perfect companion to everything else the shop has to offer.
Whole Key Lime Pie to Take Home
Buying a whole pie from Kermit’s feels like winning something. The shop boxes them up beautifully, and staff will even talk you through the best way to travel with one — because yes, people absolutely carry these pies onto planes.
The filling stays firm, the crust holds its crunch, and somehow the flavor tastes just as incredible at home as it did in Key West.
Families often order a whole pie to share at the end of a vacation day, gathered around a hotel table with plastic forks and zero regrets. Few souvenirs are this delicious or this memorable.