In Florida, some of the best pizza doesn’t come with flashy advertising — it comes with word of mouth and a loyal following. From thin-crust classics to inventive toppings, these hidden gems serve slices that are so good, locals can’t help but spread the news.
These pizza spots prove that quality, consistency, and a little local buzz can fill a restaurant without ever spending on marketing. Every visit is a chance to enjoy authentic pizza with a community vibe.
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana (Jacksonville)
Established in 1925, Frank Pepe’s brings a slice of New Haven to Jacksonville. Known for its coal-fired, thin-crust pizzas, this spot is a hit among locals. Their signature white clam pizza is often the talk of the town.
Long lines don’t deter patrons; rather, they enhance the anticipation. The old-world charm of the decor adds to the authentic dining experience.
Regulars swear by the fresh ingredients and classic recipes. Frank Pepe’s proves that sometimes tradition is the recipe for success.
Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza (Orlando)
At Anthony’s in Orlando, the aroma of coal-fired pizzas fills the air as soon as you step in. With a focus on high-quality ingredients, each pizza is crafted to perfection.
Patrons rave about the crispy crusts and tangy sauces. The bustling atmosphere complements the delicious offerings.
Pizza isn’t the only thing on the menu; their wings are also legendary. Anthony’s captures the essence of community dining, where every meal feels like a celebration.
Mazzaro’s Italian Market Pizzeria (St. Petersburg)
Mazzaro’s isn’t just a market; it’s a culinary journey. Nestled in St. Petersburg, this Italian haven offers an array of pizzas that draw in crowds.
Fresh ingredients from the market are transformed into mouthwatering pies. The lively environment makes dining here an unforgettable experience.
Visitors often find themselves returning for both the food and the vibrant market vibe. Mazzaro’s is more than a meal; it’s a slice of Italy in Florida.
Five Star Pizza (Jacksonville)
Five Star Pizza in Jacksonville might be small, but it’s mighty in flavor. Known for its friendly service and inviting atmosphere, customers feel right at home.
Their unique topping combinations keep the menu exciting, and the thin, crispy crusts are a favorite. The local community often gathers here, making it a staple in the area.
The warmth of the staff matches the comfort of the pizzas, proving that great service and delicious food go hand in hand. Star Pizza is a little gem with a big heart.
Pieology Pizzeria (Various Florida locations)
Pieology revolutionizes the pizza experience with its build-your-own approach. Scattered across Florida, this spot lets you craft your perfect pie.
The endless topping options cater to every taste, making it popular among families and groups. The simplicity of the concept belies the complexity of flavors.
Customers enjoy the casual dining style and quick service. Pieology’s success lies in its adaptability, offering a personalized pizza journey.