Some of America’s most beautiful islands aren’t the famous ones—and that’s exactly what makes them special. These are the hidden gems where time slows down, the crowds disappear, and the ocean feels like it’s all yours. Forget the overrun beaches and souvenir stands. These island towns are all about quiet harbors, family-run cafes, and sunsets that stop you in your tracks. You’ll find charm in weathered docks, salt-stung breezes, and locals who know every tide by heart.
From windswept New England coasts to sun-soaked southern shores, each one has its own rhythm—a little wild, a little nostalgic, and completely unforgettable. So skip the obvious island escapes. These 16 underrated island towns are waiting to show you a side of coastal life that feels real, raw, and beautifully off the radar.
Barra, Scotland
Evelyn und Robert Wirth/ Wikimedia CommonsImagine a place where planes land on the beach. Barra, a gem in the Outer Hebrides, offers just that. The island’s charm lies in its blend of natural beauty and unique culture.
With sandy beaches and rolling hills, Barra is perfect for those wanting a peaceful escape. The locals’ warmth makes any visitor feel at home.
Explore the historic Kisimul Castle or enjoy the local seafood delicacies. Barra’s simplicity and scenic vistas provide a perfect respite from the hustle and bustle.
Visby, Sweden
Step back in time in Visby, a UNESCO World Heritage site known for its medieval architecture. Located on the island of Gotland, Visby enchants with cobblestone streets and ancient stone walls.
Summer brings the Medieval Week, where the town transforms with markets and reenactments. The colorful gardens add to its charm.
Visby’s serene beaches and rich history make it a captivating destination. It’s a place where the past meets the present in a harmonious blend.
Milos, Greece
Milos remains one of Greece’s best-kept secrets. Known for its stunning beaches and volcanic landscape, it offers a quieter alternative to the bustling Cyclades.
Milos’ catacombs and ancient theaters tell tales of its storied past. The vibrant fishing villages add to its allure.
With fewer crowds, visitors can explore its hidden coves and crystal-clear waters freely. Milos is a sanctuary for those seeking beauty and tranquility.
Korčula, Croatia
PetrS./ Wikimedia CommonsKorčula, often dubbed ‘Little Dubrovnik,’ is a treasure trove of history and natural beauty. Ancient stone buildings and narrow streets create a picturesque setting.
The island is steeped in legend, claiming to be the birthplace of Marco Polo. Traditional dances and festivals keep its culture vibrant.
With its pristine beaches and rich culinary scene, Korčula offers an idyllic escape. Its unique blend of the old and the new captivates every traveler.
Nantucket, USA
Le grand Cricri/ Wikimedia CommonsNantucket, a New England gem, is renowned for its maritime heritage and stunning landscapes. Quaint cottages line its charming streets, offering a glimpse into a bygone era.
The island’s lighthouses and museums reflect its rich history. Meanwhile, the beaches provide endless opportunities for relaxation.
With its culinary delights and artistic community, Nantucket is a haven for culture and leisure seekers alike. Its blend of elegance and simplicity is unmatched.
Ischia, Italy
Ischia, often overshadowed by its neighbor Capri, offers thermal springs and beautiful scenery. This volcanic island in the Tyrrhenian Sea is a paradise for wellness seekers.
The gardens of La Mortella and the Aragonese Castle are must-visits. Ischia’s culinary scene, rich in seafood and local wines, delights the palate.
The island’s warm climate and welcoming locals make it an ideal year-round destination. Its tranquil landscapes invite relaxation and exploration.
Prince Edward Island, Canada
Hayden Soloviev/ Wikimedia CommonsPrince Edward Island enchants with its rolling hills, red cliffs, and pristine beaches. Known as the setting for ‘Anne of Green Gables,’ it captivates with its literary charm.
The island’s rich culture, with music festivals and artisan crafts, showcases its vibrant community. Fresh seafood, especially mussels and lobster, are culinary highlights.
PEI’s stunning landscapes and warm hospitality offer an unforgettable retreat. Its blend of nature and culture is truly special.
Flatey, Iceland
Flatey is a tiny island off Iceland’s coast, offering a unique blend of simplicity and beauty. The island’s few residents maintain its charm, surrounded by colorful houses and diverse birdlife.
Summer months bring an influx of puffins, adding to its natural allure. The island’s library and church provide cultural touches.
Flatey’s isolation creates a peaceful retreat from modern life. Its unspoiled landscapes and serene atmosphere invite relaxation and reflection.
La Digue, Seychelles
La Digue is a paradise in the Seychelles, known for its untouched beaches and granite formations. The island’s laid-back vibe and lack of cars enhance its natural beauty.
Visitors can explore by bicycle or ox-cart, uncovering hidden beaches and quaint villages. The local Creole culture adds to its charm.
La Digue’s stunning landscapes and vibrant marine life offer endless exploration opportunities. It’s a destination where nature takes center stage.
Lamu, Kenya
Lamu, a UNESCO World Heritage site, is Kenya’s oldest living town. Its Swahili architecture and vibrant markets create a unique tapestry of culture and history.
Donkeys are the primary mode of transport, adding to the town’s old-world charm. Festivals and local crafts showcase its rich traditions.
Lamu’s beaches and dhow sailing experiences offer relaxation and adventure. Its blend of history and hospitality makes it unforgettable.
Saba, Caribbean Netherlands
Saba, known as the ‘Unspoiled Queen,’ is a haven for nature lovers. This small Caribbean island boasts lush mountains and pristine waters.
The island’s hiking trails lead to breathtaking vistas, while its coral reefs are a diver’s paradise. Saba’s small villages exude charm and friendliness.
With its commitment to conservation, Saba offers an eco-friendly getaway. The island’s serenity and natural beauty create a perfect escape.
Terschelling, Netherlands
Terschelling, part of the Frisian Islands, is a Dutch treasure. Known for its sandy beaches and dunes, it offers a serene retreat.
The island’s lighthouses and cycling paths invite exploration, while the Oerol Festival brings art and culture to life.
Terschelling’s enchanting landscapes and vibrant wildlife, including seals and birds, create a nature lover’s paradise. Its peaceful ambiance is truly captivating.
Shetland, Scotland
Shetland’s rugged cliffs and rolling moors create a landscape of dramatic beauty. Located north of mainland Scotland, it offers a unique blend of Norse and Scottish heritage.
The islands are known for their vibrant festivals, including the Up Helly Aa fire festival. Local crafts and music reflect its rich culture.
Shetland’s wildlife, from seals to seabirds, adds to its natural allure. It’s a destination where history and nature intertwine.
Carriacou, Grenada
Vlad Podvorny/ Wikimedia Commons – Wikimedia.orgCarriacou, known as the ‘Land of Reefs,’ is a Caribbean gem with vibrant marine life. Its colorful boats and pristine waters invite exploration and relaxation.
The island’s festivals and traditions, such as the Maroon Music Festival, reflect its lively culture. Local cuisine, rich in spices and flavors, tantalizes the taste buds.
Carriacou’s warm community and stunning landscapes offer a refreshing escape. Its blend of culture and tranquility is truly enchanting.
Reine, Norway
Nestled within the Lofoten archipelago, Reine enchants with its rugged beauty and vibrant culture. The small fishing village offers breathtaking views of jagged peaks and tranquil waters.
Wander through its colorful wooden houses and savor fresh seafood at local eateries. The midnight sun and northern lights make Reine a haven for nature enthusiasts.
Despite its remote location, Reine is accessible and welcoming. Visitors can embark on hiking trails or boat tours to explore even more of its stunning surroundings. A unique blend of serenity and adventure awaits in this Norwegian gem.
Kaş, Turkey
Tucked away on Turkey’s southwestern coast, Kaş is a delightful blend of history and seaside charm. Known for its turquoise waters, it offers an array of water sports, including diving and kayaking.
Explore the town’s winding alleys lined with bougainvillea and ancient ruins. Kaş’s laid-back atmosphere is complemented by lively markets and cozy cafes.
Whether lounging on pebbly beaches or exploring Lycian trails, Kaş invites relaxation and exploration. Its rich history and vibrant local life make it a captivating spot for travelers seeking authenticity and beauty.