Wisconsin’s Friday fish fry tradition is a beloved cultural staple, drawing locals and visitors alike to experience the comforting flavors and community spirit.
From cozy supper clubs to bustling lakeside grills, these ten spots continue to serve up the finest fish fry experiences, ensuring that every Friday feels like a celebration of local culinary heritage.
Toby’s Supper Club – Madison
Toby’s Supper Club in Madison is a family-run gem that’s been delighting patrons for over fifty years. The warmth of tradition fills the air as you step inside, greeted by the aroma of perfectly fried fish.
Diners are treated to a classic supper club experience, complete with relish trays, dinner rolls, and a choice of potato, salad, or soup.
Adding a touch of Wisconsin flair, sides like fried cheese curds are a must-try. Locals flock here for a taste of nostalgia, where every meal is a nod to cherished traditions with a delightful twist.
The Packing House – Milwaukee
In Milwaukee, The Packing House stands as a retro icon, perfectly blending tradition with a lively atmosphere. Its proximity to the airport makes it a convenient stop for both locals and travelers.
The fish fry here is legendary, often paired with live lounge music that adds a festive touch. The Brandy Old Fashioned, a Wisconsin classic, flows freely, enhancing the experience.
For those pressed for time, their drive-thru fish-to-go service is a game-changer, but the real magic happens inside, where the bar buzzes with camaraderie and joy.
Harbor Fish Market & Grille – Baileys Harbor (Door County)
Set against the picturesque backdrop of Lake Michigan, Harbor Fish Market & Grille in Baileys Harbor offers a dining experience that is both elegant and relaxed.
The building itself, an early 20th-century marvel, exudes charm and history. Here, the fish fry becomes an elevated affair, featuring locally sourced whitefish and perch. The lakeside views complement the culinary delights, making every visit memorable.
Occasionally, diners might find themselves amidst a lobster boil, adding an unexpected twist to the evening. It’s a place where nature and nourishment seamlessly converge.
Popeye’s on Lake Geneva
Seated along the scenic shores of Lake Geneva, Popeye’s has been a family-run staple since 1971. With the capacity to host up to 600 guests, it’s a space where community and conviviality thrive.
The breaded Great Lakes yellow perch is the star of their fish fry menu, offering a taste that’s both familiar and delightful. Paired with tropical-inspired cocktails, every meal feels like a mini-vacation.
The panoramic lake views add to the allure, ensuring that Popeye’s remains a beloved Friday night destination for both locals and visitors.
The Boathouse – Minocqua (Northern Wisconsin)
Nestled in the heart of Northern Wisconsin, The Boathouse in Minocqua offers an iconic Northwoods dining experience. Set against the tranquil backdrop of Lake Minocqua, the restaurant invites guests to unwind and indulge.
While fish fry is available any night, Fridays see an influx of eager diners ready to savor the hearty, flavorful offerings. The rustic decor and cozy atmosphere create a welcoming environment, perfect for family gatherings or a quiet meal.
Scenic views and delicious fare make The Boathouse a cherished spot amidst the beauty of the Northwoods.
Lake Park Pub – Menasha (Fox Cities)
Lake Park Pub in Menasha is a local favorite, having claimed the best fish fry title seven times in local readers’ choice awards.
The menu is a seafood lover’s dream, featuring lake perch, bluegill, haddock, and walleye, all offered either breaded or beer-battered. Fridays are bustling, with diners eager to taste the award-winning offerings.
The casual setting and friendly service add to the charm. To avoid the rush, patrons often plan to dine early or late, but no matter the time, the experience is always worth the wait.
Camelot Bar & Grill – Appleton (Fox Cities)
At first glance, Camelot Bar & Grill in Appleton might appear modest, but step inside, and you’ll discover its true charm.
The unassuming exterior gives way to a bustling interior, where deep-fried pike, Icelandic haddock, and sunfish are just the beginning. Adventurous diners might even indulge in frog legs and scallops. Fridays are especially busy, with a lively crowd gathered from lunch through dinner.
The cozy atmosphere and diverse menu make Camelot a beloved spot for those seeking both traditional and unique fish fry options.
Out-O-Town Supper Club – Kaukauna (Fox Cities)
Family-operated for 35 years, Out-O-Town Supper Club in Kaukauna stands out with its welcoming charm and delightful offerings.
Friday nights are a celebration of flavors, with perch, haddock, pike, and bluegill taking center stage. The sides, including coleslaw and tartar sauce, complement the main dishes perfectly. A highlight is their epic salad bar, which features intriguing options like chicken gizzards, elevating the dining experience.
Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, the warm hospitality and memorable meals make every visit special.
1951 West – Green Bay
Dubbed as “Green Bay’s Finest” fish fry destination, 1951 West offers a contemporary dining experience with a touch of sophistication.
The variety on the menu is impressive, featuring lake perch, bluegill, beer-battered haddock, shrimp, and pan-fried walleye. Diners can mix and match with combination platters, ensuring a tailor-made meal for every palate.
Locals rave about the diverse offerings and the inviting ambiance. Whether you’re seated at a cozy booth or at the sleek bar, the culinary delights and welcoming atmosphere make it a must-visit.
Redwood Inn – Green Bay
Known for its generous portions and lively atmosphere, Redwood Inn in Green Bay is a perennial favorite for fish fry enthusiasts.
The perch and walleye are cooked to perfection, accompanied by flavorful sides that enhance the meal. What sets Redwood Inn apart is their special tartar sauce, a closely guarded recipe that locals swear by. Fridays see the place filled with patrons eager to indulge in the culinary delights.
The buzz of conversations and clinking glasses creates an inviting, warm environment, making every visit a joy.