In Wisconsin, pizza isn’t just a meal—it’s a tradition. From the bustling streets of Madison to the charming towns dotting the state, these 12 pizzerias have become local legends, keeping their dining rooms full year-round with irresistible pies and a welcoming atmosphere.
Whether you’re a lifelong resident or a first-time visitor, these spots offer more than just a slice—they offer a taste of Wisconsin’s rich culinary heritage.
Sugar River Pizza – New Glarus, Sun Prairie, Verona
Step into Sugar River Pizza, and you’re greeted with the aroma of fresh ingredients and baked crusts. Known for its creative toppings and warm atmosphere, this spot never fails to impress locals and visitors alike.
The menu offers a delightful variety that caters to all taste buds. Whether you’re in Verona or Sun Prairie, expect a dining room filled with laughter and the clinking of glasses.
With roots in New Glarus, each location maintains a unique charm that keeps diners coming back. It’s more than pizza; it’s a community gathering.
Jay’s Lanes – Mukwonago
At Jay’s Lanes, pizza culture meets bowling fun. This Mukwonago gem offers a unique combination of a bustling bowling alley and a welcoming pizza haven.
Locals cherish the time spent here, making memories over slices of generously topped pizzas. The vibrant atmosphere is infectious, drawing in families and friends.
Beyond bowling, the aroma of freshly baked dough is irresistible. Here, pizza is more than just food; it’s part of the experience that keeps the lanes and tables full.
Ian’s Pizza – Madison
Ian’s Pizza in Madison is a slice of coolness, attracting crowds with its inventive flavors and urban vibe. Known for its mac ‘n’ cheese pizza, it’s a go-to for students and professionals alike.
The open, lively environment makes it a perfect spot for casual meetups and late-night cravings. Located in the heart of the city, it’s as much a social hub as a culinary delight.
Ian’s doesn’t just serve pizza; it serves experiences. Every visit is a chance to try something new and uniquely delicious.
Larducci’s Pizzeria – Elkhorn
In Elkhorn, Larducci’s is where tradition meets taste. This cozy pizzeria is famed for its authentic recipes and family-friendly ambiance.
Regulars appreciate the rich, flavorful sauce and perfectly baked crusts that define each slice. It’s a spot where conversations flow as freely as the cheese.
A favorite among locals, Larducci’s is a testament to the enduring appeal of great pizza. Here, meals are shared, and memories are made with every visit.
Tony & Maria’s – Beloit
Tony & Maria’s in Beloit encapsulates the essence of Italian dining. Known for its authentic recipes and intimate setting, it’s a beloved spot among locals.
The menu, rich with tradition, offers pizzas that are a feast for the senses. Each bite tells a story of heritage and passion.
Guests are treated like family, adding to the warmth and charm that define this pizzeria. It’s a little slice of Italy in Wisconsin.
Domenico’s – Beloit
Domenico’s in Beloit is where Italian cuisine finds its home. With an expansive menu and a lively atmosphere, it’s an inviting place for family gatherings.
The pizza, crafted with precision, is a highlight at this bustling restaurant. Patrons savor every slice, often returning for more.
Domenico’s isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a celebration of food and culture that keeps its dining room buzzing year-round.
Harry’s Pizza e Vino – Elkhart Lake
Harry’s Pizza e Vino in Elkhart Lake pairs pizza with the perfect wine, creating a delightful dining experience. This charming spot is a favorite among couples and wine enthusiasts.
The intimate setting and carefully curated menu make every visit special. Each pizza is a masterpiece, complemented by a selection of fine wines.
At Harry’s, it’s not just about the food; it’s the harmonious blend of flavors and ambiance that keeps diners enamored.
Rustique Pizza & Lounge – Suamico
Rustique Pizza & Lounge in Suamico is where rustic charm meets culinary innovation. Known for its artisanal pizzas, it’s a haven for food lovers.
The lounge offers a cozy yet lively vibe, perfect for a night out. Patrons appreciate the creativity infused into each dish.
Rustique isn’t merely a place to eat; it’s a creative culinary journey that keeps its dining room bustling with enthusiastic diners.
Buffalo Phil’s Pizza & Grille – Wisconsin Dells
In Wisconsin Dells, Buffalo Phil’s Pizza & Grille turns dining into an adventure. This themed restaurant captivates visitors with its playful decor and expansive menu.
Families flock here for the fun atmosphere and delicious pizzas. The unique train-delivered food adds a whimsical touch to the dining experience.
Buffalo Phil’s isn’t just about great food; it’s about creating magical memories that make every visit memorable.