Wisconsin boasts an impressive array of pizza places that continue to attract weekend crowds. From Milwaukee to Madison, each spot offers something unique that keeps visitors coming back for more. Here are nine beloved pizza destinations in Wisconsin that deserve a visit.
Zaffiro’s Pizza — Milwaukee
Zaffiro’s Pizza is a Milwaukee legend celebrated for its razor-thin crusts. Established in 1954, this family-run pizzeria crafts each pie with exceptional attention to detail.
Many locals swear by the unique blend of crispy crust and generous toppings. The nostalgic atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a favorite gathering place.
Whether it’s the classic sausage or a specialty creation, Zaffiro’s ensures a memorable experience. A must-visit for anyone in search of authentic Milwaukee pizza.
San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana — Milwaukee
San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana brings a slice of Naples to Milwaukee. Known for its authentic Neapolitan pizzas, each pie is cooked in a wood-fired oven.
The owner’s dedication to Italian tradition is evident in every bite, with ingredients sourced both locally and from Italy. The cozy setting offers a warm ambiance perfect for family and friends.
Try the Margherita for a pure, unadulterated taste of Italy in Wisconsin. A delightful spot for traditional pizza lovers.
Santino’s Little Italy — Milwaukee (Bay View)
Nestled in Bay View, Santino’s Little Italy is a charming spot known for its welcoming vibe. This pizzeria captures the essence of a small Italian bistro with its handcrafted pizzas.
The artistic decor and friendly staff enhance the dining experience, making it a local favorite. Diners rave about the fresh ingredients and creative combinations like the ‘Santino’s Special.’
Perfect for a casual night out or a special occasion, Santino’s offers a delightful slice of Italy in Milwaukee.
Wells Brothers — Racine
Wells Brothers in Racine has been serving legendary pizzas since 1921. This historic establishment is famous for its thin, cracker-like crust and unique toppings.
The welcoming atmosphere, coupled with a rich history, makes it an essential stop on any pizza lover’s journey.
Their pepperoni pizza is a standout, combining tradition with exceptional flavor. Wells Brothers continues to draw generations of families and newcomers alike. A true Racine treasure.
Ian’s Pizza — Madison
Ian’s Pizza in Madison has redefined what pizza can be with its quirky and inventive toppings. From mac n’ cheese to BBQ chicken, the options are delightfully unconventional.
The vibrant atmosphere and commitment to creativity attract a diverse crowd, including students and families.
Whether you’re a pizza purist or an adventurous eater, Ian’s has something for everyone. It’s not just pizza; it’s an experience. A must-visit for those seeking something different.
Grampa’s Pizzeria — Madison
Grampa’s Pizzeria is a hidden gem in Madison known for its artisanal approach. The pizzas here are crafted with care, using locally sourced, organic ingredients.
The intimate setting, complete with rustic decor, offers a charming dining experience. The ‘Grampa’s Special’ is a crowd-pleaser, featuring a perfect balance of flavors.
A great spot for a romantic dinner or a cozy gathering with friends. Grampa’s combines quality with creativity in every slice.
Salvatore’s Tomato Pies (Madison / Monona / Sun Prairie)
Salvatore’s Tomato Pies is a modern pizzeria that has captivated pizza enthusiasts across its multiple locations. Known for its tomato-forward approach, each pie is a flavor-packed delight.
The industrial-chic decor and energetic atmosphere make it a vibrant dining destination. Signature pies like the ‘Badger’ highlight regional ingredients and bold flavors.
Salvatore’s commitment to quality and creativity draws a loyal following. A staple for pizza lovers in the area.
Pizza Brutta — Madison
Pizza Brutta in Madison honors the art of pizza-making with its wood-fired creations. The focus here is on simplicity and freshness, with each pizza made from scratch.
The family-friendly environment and open kitchen invite diners to enjoy the process of artisanal pizza crafting.
Try the ‘Margherita’ for a taste of tradition or explore innovative seasonal offerings. Pizza Brutta is a celebration of authentic flavors in a warm setting.
Rustique – Suamico
Rustique in Suamico offers a unique dining experience in a converted barn. With its rustic charm, this pizzeria is perfect for those seeking a relaxed, countryside vibe.
The menu features creative options, with pizzas cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven. The outdoor patio is a favorite during warm months, providing a serene setting.
Rustique’s blend of atmosphere and flavor makes it a standout destination. A delightful escape for pizza lovers seeking something special.