Some sandwiches fill you up—but a great Reuben changes your mood. The crunch of toasted rye, the tang of sauerkraut, the melt of Swiss, and that glorious drizzle of Thousand Island—it’s a flavor symphony Wisconsin knows how to conduct. From cozy taverns to hidden diners, the Badger State has turned this deli classic into an art form. You’ll find corned beef stacked sky-high, homemade dressings that demand attention, and locals who swear this is the one sandwich worth the drive.
So grab your appetite and your napkins—these nine Wisconsin spots don’t just serve Reubens, they redefine what “sandwich perfection” means.
McBob’s Pub & Grill — Milwaukee, WI
At McBob’s Pub & Grill, the mini Reuben sandwich takes center stage in a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Known for its generous portions, McBob’s offers a lively neighborhood vibe that draws locals for both food and camaraderie.
Their Reuben features sous-vide corned beef, melted Swiss, and a house-made sauce, all nestled between slices of rye bread. This local landmark is a must-visit for anyone seeking hearty comfort food.
Whether you’re a Milwaukee native or a visitor, McBob’s charms with its mix of pub allure and mouthwatering Reuben satisfaction.
Rochester Deli — Waukesha, WI
Rochester Deli proudly claims the title “Home of the Best Reuben,” centering its identity around this iconic sandwich. The deli-style craftsmanship is evident in every bite, with generous portions of corned beef, cheese, and kraut.
Their classic pressed Reuben, served hot on marbled rye, showcases the careful assembly that keeps patrons returning for more.
For those on a Wisconsin Reuben pilgrimage, Rochester Deli is a compelling stop thanks to its sterling reputation and focused approach to this beloved sandwich.
The Rustic Roost — Iron River, WI
The Rustic Roost in northern Wisconsin delivers a Reuben experience rooted in local charm and fresh ingredients. Situated in Iron River, this café crafts its sandwich with care, featuring corned beef, sauerkraut, and Swiss on rye.
What truly sets it apart is the house-made Thousand Island dressing, adding a personal touch to a classic favorite.
This small-town gem offers a satisfying Reuben, proving that great food can be found far from the big city hustle.
Swingin’ Door Exchange — Milwaukee, WI
Swingin’ Door Exchange is a downtown Milwaukee staple where history and flavor blend seamlessly. Known for its spacious bar setting, this venue offers a Reuben that consistently ranks among the city’s finest.
The sandwich, with its hearty corned beef and Swiss cheese, is a favorite pick on local review sites.
For those seeking a taste of Milwaukee’s past paired with a modern twist on a classic, Swingin’ Door provides the perfect escape.
Mader’s Restaurant — Milwaukee, WI
At Mader’s Restaurant, the Reuben is enveloped in a rich tapestry of German heritage and old-world elegance. This historic venue, established in 1902, provides a distinctive dining experience.
Their Reuben is frequently recommended among the best in Milwaukee, marrying corned beef with sauerkraut and Swiss in an upscale setting.
Enjoy a meal steeped in history, where every bite of the Reuben is a nod to Milwaukee’s European roots.
Erin’s Snug Irish Pub — Madison, WI
Erin’s Snug Irish Pub fuses Irish pub warmth with a menu of robust sandwiches. Praised in local reviews, their Reuben stands out for its generous portions and cozy ambiance.
Featuring classic ingredients like corned beef and Swiss on rye, it’s a favorite among Madison locals.
For those who cherish a comforting pub feel, Erin’s Snug offers a Reuben experience that combines hearty satisfaction with friendly hospitality.
Stalzy’s Deli — Madison, WI
In the heart of Madison, Stalzy’s Deli crafts a Reuben that’s both authentic and innovative. Known for in-house curing and hand-crafted ingredients, this deli is a haven for sandwich aficionados.
The stacked Reuben, rich with corned beef, Swiss cheese, and house dressing, is a testament to their commitment to quality.
For those seeking a thoughtfully constructed Reuben, Stalzy’s is a Madison favorite that blends tradition with excellence.
Two Brothers Downtown Pub & Grill — Edgerton, WI
Nestled in Edgerton, Two Brothers Downtown Pub & Grill serves a Reuben that has captured local hearts. Known for its hometown friendliness, generous sandwiches, and local recognition, it’s a must-visit.
Their Reuben is often cited in social media buzz as a hidden gem worth discovering.
This spot offers a taste of Wisconsin’s rural charm, where community and flavor come together in perfect harmony.
Sweet Home Wisconsin — Madison, WI
Sweet Home Wisconsin in Madison combines regional flavors with comforting classics. This local café draws a steady stream of neighborhood regulars seeking delicious sandwiches.
Their Reuben, recommended by locals on various review platforms, embodies a mix of cozy charm and reliable taste.
For those wanting a tucked-away option that’s both familiar and delightful, Sweet Home Wisconsin offers the perfect culinary escape.