When most people think of an island getaway in the U.S., their minds leap straight to places like Maui, Key West, or Nantucket — stunning, sure, but also crowded, pricey, and increasingly commercialized. What many travelers don’t realize is that the American coastline is dotted with dozens of under-the-radar islands, each with its own vibe, scenery, and sense of solitude.
These lesser-known islands offer everything from wild horses and secluded beaches to mossy forests and tiny fishing villages. They’re the kinds of places where you can still find a mom-and-pop diner with no online presence, bike from one end of the island to the other in an afternoon, or stumble upon a beach where you’re the only person for miles. Some are accessible by ferry, bridge, or even foot at low tide, while others feel so remote they may as well be in another century.
If you’re looking for an American island escape that doesn’t require a passport or elbowing your way through tourist crowds, these 14 offbeat gems deserve a spot on your travel radar. Chances are, most of your friends haven’t heard of them — and that’s exactly the point.
Tangier Island, Virginia
Step into a time capsule with Tangier Island, Virginia, where history whispers through its unique dialect and seafood shacks. Accessible only by boat, this Chesapeake Bay island offers an intimate glimpse into the watermen culture. As you wander, you’ll feel the pace of life slow down. Immerse yourself in a community that cherishes its traditions.
Stroll past charming cottages and savor the simple joys of island life. Tangier’s serene landscapes and genuine warmth make it a must-visit for those seeking a reprieve from modernity. It’s a world away, yet so invitingly close.
Daufuskie Island, South Carolina
On Daufuskie Island, South Carolina, cars give way to golf carts and moss-draped oaks line the roads. This island whispers secrets of a rich Gullah history, woven into the fabric of its quiet beaches. Accessible only by ferry from Hilton Head, it’s a sanctuary of peace and heritage.
The island’s untouched charm captivates the soul, offering a glimpse into a simpler time. As you explore, the echoes of past generations linger. Daufuskie’s allure lies in its timeless beauty and the stories hidden in its sandy shores.
Sapelo Island, Georgia
Sapelo Island, Georgia, stands as a guardian of Gullah-Geechee culture, one of the last islands preserving this vibrant heritage. Its wild beaches and lighthouse ruins tell tales of a bygone era. State-managed ferries keep the modern world at bay, making it a haven for those seeking solitude.
As you tread its sandy paths, you’ll be enveloped by the island’s untamed beauty. Sapelo’s landscapes are a testament to nature’s artistry, unspoiled and raw. It’s a retreat where history and nature converge, offering a peaceful escape from the everyday.
Whidbey Island, Washington
Whidbey Island, Washington, is a sanctuary in the Pacific Northwest, where cliffs and coves merge with an artsy vibe. Just a short drive or ferry from Seattle, this island offers a peaceful retreat from the city rush.
Its lavender farms and creative spirit beckon those who seek inspiration. As you wander its scenic trails, let the island’s tranquil beauty wash over you. Whidbey’s charm lies in its harmonious blend of nature and creativity, making it a haven for dreamers and adventurers alike.
Block Island, Rhode Island
Off the coast but worlds away, Block Island, Rhode Island, captivates with its cliffside trails and timeless New England charm. This island offers an escape from the Newport crowds, where nature’s beauty unfolds at every turn.
Lighthouses watch over the rocky shores, guiding visitors to hidden wonders. Let the island’s serene atmosphere envelop you as you explore. Here, the pace of life is gentle, inviting you to unwind and savor the simple pleasures of coastal living.
Little St. Simons Island, Georgia
Little St. Simons Island, Georgia, is a sanctuary for nature enthusiasts, where only 32 guests are allowed at a time. This private, eco-friendly island boasts untouched marshes and abundant birdwatching opportunities.
Guided nature tours reveal the island’s hidden treasures, offering a closer look at its rich biodiversity. The tranquility found here is unparalleled, with nature’s symphony as your backdrop. Little St. Simons is a retreat into the wild, where the call of the natural world reigns supreme.
North Haven, Maine
Nestled in Penobscot Bay, North Haven, Maine, is both a lobster village and a literary escape. Simplicity reigns here, with breathtaking ocean views and a serene atmosphere.
This tiny island offers a quiet respite from the chaos of everyday life. As you explore, the island’s beauty unfolds with every step. North Haven’s unpretentious charm and natural landscapes create a perfect backdrop for reflection and relaxation. It’s a place where the soul can breathe freely.
Lopez Island, Washington
In the shadow of its flashier neighbors, Lopez Island, Washington, offers a laid-back retreat in the San Juans. Known for its bike-friendly paths and hidden coves, this island beckons those who seek simplicity.
Farm stands dot the landscape, offering fresh, local delights. The island’s welcoming spirit and tranquil beauty provide a perfect setting for leisurely exploration. Lopez Island invites you to slow down and savor life’s simple pleasures, away from the hustle and bustle.
Santa Rosa Island, Florida
Tucked between Pensacola and Destin, Santa Rosa Island, Florida, boasts some of the whitest sand beaches in the U.S. Here, open spaces invite exploration, with fewer people and more room to roam.
The island’s natural beauty is a canvas for adventure, from beachcombing to soaking in the sun. Santa Rosa offers a serene escape from the crowded shores, where tranquility and pristine landscapes are the stars. It’s a haven for those who crave peace amidst nature’s wonders.
Isle au Haut, Maine
Partially managed by Acadia National Park, Isle au Haut, Maine, is a remote haven for hikers and campers. Rugged trails lead to breathtaking vistas, where nature’s raw beauty takes center stage.
With no shops or noise, the island offers a retreat into solitude. Here, the wilderness is your companion, and the stars your guide. Isle au Haut beckons those who seek adventure and tranquility in equal measure, a place where the soul can truly connect with nature.
Cumberland Island, Georgia
Cumberland Island, Georgia, is a sanctuary of wild horses and mossy trails. This protected national seashore, once home to Carnegie mansions, offers a hauntingly beautiful escape.
Explore the island’s rich history and natural wonders at your own pace. The echoes of the past linger in the air, inviting reflection and discovery. Cumberland’s untouched landscapes and historic charm create an experience that feels both otherworldly and deeply rooted in history.
Dry Tortugas, Florida
Accessible only by boat or seaplane, Dry Tortugas, Florida, is home to the historic Fort Jefferson. Surrounded by some of the clearest snorkeling waters in the U.S., this island feels like a well-kept secret.
Dive into a world of underwater wonders, where vibrant marine life thrives. The fort’s storied past adds a layer of intrigue, blending history with natural beauty. Dry Tortugas is a destination where adventure and exploration are the order of the day.
Plum Island, Massachusetts
Just outside Newburyport, Plum Island, Massachusetts, is a haven for birdwatchers, beachcombers, and lighthouse lovers. Its vintage summer charm and relaxed pace offer a refreshing change of scenery.
Explore sandy shores and discover the island’s natural beauty at every turn. Plum Island’s inviting landscapes and gentle ambiance create a perfect setting for leisurely adventures. Whether you’re drawn to its beaches or its history, this island promises a delightful escape.
Santa Cruz Island, California
Part of Channel Islands National Park, Santa Cruz Island, California, is often called the state’s Galápagos. Here, sea caves and dolphins grace the waters, offering a glimpse into a world untouched by tourist traps.
Explore its diverse ecosystems and encounter wildlife in its natural habitat. Santa Cruz’s rugged beauty and serene landscapes make it a paradise for nature enthusiasts. It’s a place where the wonders of the natural world come to life in vivid detail.