When you think of New Haven, chances are pizza comes to mind first. This Connecticut city has built a worldwide reputation for its coal-fired pies, legendary family-run pizzerias, and a food culture that revolves around the perfect slice. Locals even have a name for it — apizza — and once you’ve tried it here, you’ll understand why it’s unlike anything else.
So if you’re ready to taste the essence of New Haven’s food scene, these 7 iconic pizza places are the ones every visitor (and local) should experience at least once.
Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana
Who would have thought that a simple clam could revolutionize a pizza? Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana, established in 1925, is a gem in New Haven’s crown. Renowned for its white clam pie, Pepe’s has charmed locals and tourists alike with its crispy, coal-fired crust. The atmosphere is a blend of nostalgia and warmth, inviting patrons to savor every bite. Generations have enjoyed the iconic flavors here, a testament to its enduring legacy. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular, this pizzeria promises a delightful experience every time.
Sally’s Apizza
In 1938, Sally’s Apizza opened its doors, serving what many argue is New Haven’s best pizza. Known for its tomato pies, the pizzeria has a loyal following. Each pizza features a thin, crispy crust, perfectly complemented by a rich sauce and fresh toppings. The charm of Sally’s lies in its simplicity and tradition. A visit to New Haven isn’t complete without experiencing the authentic taste that Sally’s delivers. This beloved spot remains a staple in the community, cherishing its roots while continually welcoming new guests.
Modern Apizza
Established in 1934, Modern Apizza offers a fresh take on the traditional New Haven pizza. Located on State Street, it is known for its generous toppings and perfectly balanced crust. The pizzeria has a contemporary vibe, making it a favorite for both locals and visitors. Notably, their Italian Bomb pizza, loaded with meats and veggies, captures the essence of hearty, satisfying dining. Modern Apizza successfully combines innovation with tradition, ensuring that each visit is memorable. It’s a place where flavors and community come together harmoniously.
Zuppardi’s Apizza
For over 80 years, Zuppardi’s Apizza has been a family affair, known for its dedication to quality and tradition. Located in West Haven, this spot offers pizzas that are lovingly crafted. Their fresh clam pizza is a standout, reflecting their Italian heritage and commitment to fresh ingredients. The family-oriented environment makes guests feel right at home. Whether you’re enjoying a meal with loved ones or picking up a takeout, Zuppardi’s assures a satisfying experience filled with authentic flavors and heartfelt service.
Da Legna at Nolo
Da Legna at Nolo redefines what pizza can be with its artistic approach to flavors and presentation. Known for its inventive toppings and artisanal crusts, this pizzeria stands out in a city full of traditional options. The atmosphere is stylish yet inviting, perfect for a relaxed meal. Their seasonal vegetable pizza showcases their commitment to fresh, local ingredients, resulting in a dish that’s as beautiful as it is delicious. Da Legna at Nolo is a testament to the creativity and evolution within New Haven’s pizza scene.
Ernie’s Pizzeria
Tucked away in a quiet corner, Ernie’s Pizzeria offers a no-frills approach to pizza making. This cozy spot focuses on delivering quality through simplicity. Known for its classic cheese pizza, Ernie’s attracts those who appreciate a straightforward, delicious pie. The friendly staff and inviting environment add to its charm, making every visit feel like coming home. Ernie’s has managed to carve out a niche for itself, emphasizing that sometimes less is truly more when it comes to great pizza.
Grand Apizza
Grand Apizza, with its roots deeply embedded in the community, serves as a gathering place for friends and families. Known for its pepperoni pizza, which offers a satisfying crunch with every bite, it has become a favorite among locals. The friendly service and welcoming atmosphere make it a reliable choice for any pizza lover. Grand Apizza is not just about the food; it’s about creating memories and sharing moments over a delicious slice.