When it comes to bagels, New York City is often seen as the gold standard. Yet, Connecticut’s vibrant bagel scene is proving to be a worthy contender.
From hand-rolled, boiled classics to innovative flavors and spreads, these ten Connecticut bagel shops offer a delightful experience for any bagel enthusiast.
Each shop brings its own unique flair, making them must-visit spots for both locals and visitors.
Whether you crave a traditional bite or something with a modern twist, these establishments promise to satisfy your bagel cravings.
Goldberg’s Bagel Café
In West Hartford, Goldberg’s Bagel Café stands as a testament to the art of traditional bagel-making. This family-run gem offers classic New York–style water bagels that are boiled, hand-rolled, and baked to perfection.
The café’s everything bagel paired with scallion cream cheese is a local legend and a must-try for visitors. The cozy setting and welcoming atmosphere make it a beloved spot.
Goldberg’s combines authenticity with charm, drawing in a loyal crowd of bagel aficionados.
Lox Stock & Bagels
With multiple locations in West Hartford, Newington, and Granby, Lox Stock & Bagels offers a consistently delightful bagel experience.
Known for their soft-yet-chewy texture, their bagels cater to a wide range of tastes. Particularly popular is their smoked salmon bagel sandwich, a favorite among New York City transplants.
The atmosphere is lively, and each location maintains a high standard of quality. Lox Stock & Bagels is more than just a shop; it’s a community hub for bagel lovers.
Bagel Delight
Located in Newtown, Bagel Delight has been serving delectable bagels since 1992. This neighborhood favorite handcrafts over 20 varieties daily, ensuring fresh quality with every bite.
The shop has a bustling, community-first vibe that gives it a true neighborhood feel. Regulars praise the inviting atmosphere and the friendly service.
Bagel Delight is a staple in the area, where quality and community come together. A visit here guarantees delicious bagels and a warm welcome.
Brooklyn Baking Company
Despite its name, Brooklyn Baking Company is a Waterbury favorite with deep Connecticut roots. Founded in 1941, the shop still adheres to traditional bagel-making techniques that result in a chewy crust cherished by purists.
The ambiance is nostalgic, evoking a sense of timelessness. Whether you are a newcomer or a regular, the quality remains consistently high.
This establishment is a cherished local icon, blending history with exceptional taste.
Cohen’s Bagel Company
Cohen’s Bagel Company in Madison boasts a blend of New York tradition and local Connecticut charm.
Founded by a New York transplant, this shop delivers dense, chewy bagels that rival the best from the Bronx or Brooklyn. Their house-made schmears are an added delight, complementing the rich bagel flavors.
As a shoreline favorite, Cohen’s is celebrated for its authenticity and friendly service. It’s a place where bagel lovers feel right at home.
Bagelman
A Connecticut favorite since 1995, Bagelman crafts kettle-boiled, hand-rolled bagels that deliver classic New York flavor with local charm.
With several locations across Fairfield County, it’s known for fresh ingredients, fast service, and a devoted fan base that insists it rivals the best of NYC.
Village Bagels
Village Bagels, with locations in Norwalk and Ridgefield, serves up authentic New York–style bagels. Kettle-boiled and baked fresh every morning, these bagels have become a staple for many.
The Ridgefield shop is especially noted for its creative cream cheese flavors that add a delightful twist to the classic bagel.
With a warm atmosphere and excellent service, Village Bagels is a go-to destination for bagel enthusiasts.
Bagel Bros & Co.
Located in Shelton, Connecticut, Bagel Bros & Co. has earned a stellar reputation for crafting some of the state’s best bagels.
Known for their diverse selection of 16 unique flavors and fresh, hand-rolled dough, this shop offers everything from classic favorites to inventive creations like their signature “The Shelton.”
With a focus on quality and community, Bagel Bros & Co. serves up delicious bagels daily, making it a must-visit spot for bagel lovers across Connecticut.
PopUp Bagels
PopUp Bagels in Westport, Connecticut, has gained fame for serving oven-hot, hand-rolled bagels with simple yet flavorful schmears.
Known for their “Grip, Rip and Dip” eating style, they offer a unique bagel experience that has earned national attention and a devoted following.
With creative rotating spreads and a focus on quality, PopUp Bagels is a must-try for anyone craving fresh, delicious bagels in the area.
Badass Bagels
Badass Bagels in Norwalk, Connecticut, brings a bold and creative twist to traditional bagels.
Known for their vibrant atmosphere and inventive spreads, they offer a wide variety of freshly made bagels that keep locals coming back for more.
Perfect for those who want a flavorful and satisfying bagel experience, Badass Bagels stands out as a local favorite in the Norwalk community.