Pittsburgh’s neighborhoods are filled with reminders of the city’s immigrant roots, and nowhere is that more delicious than at its Italian delis. These shops serve more than just sandwiches — they carry on family recipes, community traditions, and flavors that have been part of the city for generations.
From stuffed hoagies and classic Italian subs to imported cheeses and homemade specialties, these delis are proof that great food and history go hand in hand. Here are ten that locals swear by when the craving for old-school Italian flavor strikes.
Pennsylvania Macaroni Co.
Known affectionately as “Penn Mac” by locals, this deli has been a cornerstone of the Strip District since 1902. The aroma of aged cheeses and cured meats fills the air, promising sandwiches that burst with authenticity.
In a city known for its culinary diversity, Penn Mac stands out with its vast selection of imported Italian delicacies, adding a touch of nostalgia with every bite.
Visitors often find themselves lost in time while exploring the aisles, reminiscent of old-world markets. The rich history of Penn Mac is as flavorful as its sandwiches, making it a must-visit for anyone in Pittsburgh.
Jimmy & Nino Sunseri Co.
Nestled in the bustling Strip District, Jimmy & Nino Sunseri Co. is a family-owned treasure. Known for its authentic Italian sandwiches, this deli captures the essence of tradition and family.
The familiar faces behind the counter and the cheerful chatter create an atmosphere that feels like home. Each sandwich is a masterpiece, crafted with love and authenticity.
A visit here is more than just a meal; it’s a journey into the heart of Italian-American culture. The legacy of Sunseri Co. is tangible with every bite, making it an essential stop for food lovers.
Groceria Italiana
In the lively neighborhood of Bloomfield, Groceria Italiana serves as a cultural landmark. The deli’s sandwiches are a testament to the enduring Italian influence in Pittsburgh.
With each bite, patrons are transported to Italy, tasting the love and dedication in every ingredient. The warm, welcoming atmosphere beckons visitors to stay awhile.
Known for its freshly baked bread and premium meats, Groceria Italiana is a celebration of authentic flavors. The deli’s commitment to tradition makes it a beloved fixture in the community, cherished by locals and newcomers alike.
Labriola’s Italian Market
With multiple locations across Pittsburgh, Labriola’s Italian Market offers an authentic taste of Italy. The original store in Aspinwall is particularly charming, exuding a small-town feel.
Each sandwich from Labriola’s is crafted with care, showcasing the finest Italian ingredients. It’s the perfect spot for those who appreciate quality and tradition.
The market is a sensory delight, with rows of imported goods that complement their famous sandwiches. Labriola’s commitment to excellence makes it a favorite among locals and visitors, eager to savor a piece of Italian heritage.
Slice on Broadway’s Deli Counter
Known for its pizzas, Slice on Broadway’s deli counter in Beechview offers a surprising delight—Italian sandwiches that command attention.
Each sandwich is a bold statement, marrying robust flavors with fresh ingredients, crafted to satisfy even the most discerning palate.
The inviting space encourages diners to linger, enjoying the vibrant community atmosphere. Whether you’re a regular or a first-timer, Slice on Broadway promises an experience that’s as memorable as their sandwiches are delicious.
Moio’s Italian Pastry Shop & Deli
While renowned for its pastries, Moio’s in Monroeville surprises with its Italian deli offerings. The sandwiches here are a hidden gem, brimming with authentic flavors.
The combination of freshly baked bread and traditional fillings creates a taste sensation that’s hard to forget. Moio’s embraces its dual identity, excelling in both sweets and savory.
Patrons are often drawn in by the pastries but leave singing praises of the deli sandwiches. It’s a delightful culinary contradiction that works harmoniously, offering something for everyone.
Italian Village Pizza & Deli
In South Hills, Italian Village Pizza & Deli offers more than just pies. The deli sandwiches are crafted with a passion for Italian tradition and a flair for innovation.
The cozy setting makes it a perfect spot for a casual meal, attracting a loyal customer base who appreciate quality and taste.
Here, the sandwiches are as much a work of art as the pizzas, ensuring that every visit is a feast for the senses. Italian Village stands as a testament to the enduring appeal of Italian cuisine in Pittsburgh.
Colangelo’s Bakery & Deli
Nestled in the vibrant Strip District, Colangelo’s combines the best of Italian baking with delightful deli sandwiches.
The aroma of freshly baked bread and rich fillings greets every visitor, promising a meal that’s as satisfying as it is flavorful.
Colangelo’s is a gathering place for locals and tourists alike, drawn by the promise of quality and taste. Each sandwich is a masterpiece, a delicious tribute to Pittsburgh’s Italian roots, offering a warm embrace with every bite.