Georgia is home to a vibrant pizza scene that rivals any national chain with its unique flavors and local charm.
From Neapolitan-style masterpieces to massive New York slices, these pizzerias are the pride of their communities.
Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these spots promise an unforgettable dining experience.
Antico Pizza Napoletana (Atlanta, GA)
Nestled in the heart of Atlanta, Antico Pizza Napoletana serves up authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas that have captured the hearts of locals. Their wood-fired oven perfects blistered, cheesy pies topped with fresh mozzarella and imported Italian ingredients. The communal seating adds to the lively, unpretentious atmosphere.
The BYOB policy invites a relaxed, personal experience, making it a favorite spot for gatherings with friends and family. Each bite transports you straight to Naples.
The open kitchen lets you witness the skilled chefs work their magic, crafting pizzas with precision and passion.
Vito’s Pizza & Ristorante (Alpharetta, GA)
A beloved neighborhood spot, Vito’s brings authentic Italian comfort to Alpharetta with its hand-tossed New York-style pizzas, homemade pastas, and welcoming, family-owned charm.
Regulars rave about the crispy-yet-chewy crust, generous toppings, and warm service that feels more like dining at a friend’s house than a restaurant.
For those craving a slice with soul, Vito’s is a standout locals choose time and again over the chains.
Fellini’s Pizza (Multiple ATL Locations)
Since the 1980s, Fellini’s Pizza has been an Atlanta staple, beloved for its quirky, retro charm and deliciously oversized slices. The laid-back atmosphere draws in regulars who crave hearty toppings and a nostalgic dining experience.
Each location offers a unique vibe, but the commitment to quality remains consistent. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or settling in for a leisurely meal, Fellini’s promises satisfaction.
Their dedication to authenticity and fun sets them apart from any chain, making them a true Atlanta icon.
Big Pie in the Sky (Kennesaw & Roswell, GA)
Big Pie in the Sky is famous for its enormous 30-inch pizzas and the legendary “Carnivore Challenge.” This Kennesaw and Roswell favorite attracts college students and families alike, offering value and unforgettable slices.
The challenge, a viral sensation, dares guests to finish a meat-laden pie within a set time, offering bragging rights and a fun experience. But even without the challenge, the pizzas here impress with their size and quality.
The friendly, bustling environment makes it a perfect spot for casual dining and memorable gatherings.
Mellow Mushroom (Originated in Atlanta, GA)
Though now a national sensation, Mellow Mushroom began as a funky Atlanta gem. Known for its psychedelic décor and stone-baked crusts, this pizzeria remains a favorite for many Georgians seeking a local touch.
Each location retains its unique style, offering creative toppings that defy ordinary pizza conventions. The whimsical environment invites laughter and enjoyment, making it a perfect spot for families and friends.
Mellow Mushroom’s dedication to freshness and innovation ensures that even as a franchise, it holds a special place in its hometown hearts.
Johnny’s New York Style Pizza (Various Georgia Locations)
Johnny’s New York Style Pizza might have several franchises, but it maintains a distinctly local feel, especially in Georgia’s smaller towns. Its foldable, crispy New York slices are perfect for those craving classic East Coast flavor.
The welcoming vibe and consistent quality have built a loyal customer base that appreciates the simplicity and taste of every pie.
While it might expand, Johnny’s never loses that local charm that keeps patrons coming back for more. Each visit feels like catching up with an old friend.
Blue Moon Pizza (Smyrna, Marietta, Sandy Springs, Buckhead)
Blue Moon Pizza stands out for its thin-crust pies with bold flavors and innovative toppings. Located in multiple areas, it offers an upscale casual vibe that draws in a diverse crowd seeking more than just pizza.
The bar scene adds to the lively atmosphere, making it a social hotspot perfect for gatherings. Each pie is crafted with precision, ensuring a taste that’s memorable and unique.
Blue Moon’s dedication to quality and creativity makes it a beloved choice among locals who appreciate both ambiance and flavor.
Your Pie (Athens, GA – now franchised)
Your Pie, originating in Athens, revolutionized the fast-casual, build-your-own pizza concept before it became a widespread trend. The flagship location still draws locals and students seeking a personalized pizza experience.
Inspired by Italian tradition, each pie is crafted with care, allowing diners to choose from a variety of fresh ingredients. The lively, collegiate environment adds to its charm, making it a popular spot for both locals and visitors.
Despite its growth, Your Pie retains its community roots and continues to serve up delicious, customizable pizzas.
Rosa’s Pizza (Downtown Atlanta, GA)
Tucked near Georgia State University, Rosa’s Pizza is a downtown Atlanta institution. Known for its giant, perfectly greasy slices, it’s a go-to for students and office workers seeking quality and value.
Fast service and no-frills décor create a straightforward dining experience that regulars cherish. Each slice delivers that authentic New York taste, complete with a satisfying, chewy crust.
Rosa’s continues to be a favorite lunch stop for those wanting a break from the ordinary, offering a taste that rivals any national chain.