Italian food in Delaware hides in the most unassuming spots. You wouldn’t expect a strip-mall diner or a small-town eatery to serve pasta that tastes like it came straight from Nonna’s kitchen—but here, it does. These diners take simple ingredients—fresh tomatoes, hand-rolled pasta, quality cheeses—and turn them into dishes that demand attention. Meatballs simmer in rich sauces, lasagna layers are perfectly baked, and every bite carries the kind of flavor that makes you close your eyes and savor it.
If you’re hunting for Italian dishes that surprise and delight, these 9 Delaware diners prove that extraordinary flavors don’t need a fancy facade. You just need a good appetite.
Mrs. Robino’s Restaurant
Tucked away near Trolley Square, Mrs. Robino’s Restaurant offers more than meets the eye. Since 1940, this family-run gem has been captivating patrons with its homemade pasta and classic Italian-American dishes. The vintage decor and unpretentious atmosphere create a nostalgic dining experience.
Known for generous portions and rich flavors, Mrs. Robino’s has become a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike. The warm and welcoming staff add to the charm, making every visit feel like a family gathering. Whether it’s the tender meatballs or the savory sauces, every dish tells a story of tradition and passion.
Ristorante Attilio
In the heart of Wilmington’s Little Italy lies Ristorante Attilio, a culinary icon since 1985. This charming restaurant delights diners with handmade Italian dishes, emphasizing traditional recipes passed down through generations.
The warm ambiance transports guests to an Italian family home, where veal and seafood specialties reign supreme. Committed to using quality ingredients, Ristorante Attilio delivers a memorable dining experience. Each dish reflects a love for authentic flavors, creating a symphony of taste that leaves a lasting impression. It’s a place where family and food unite, offering a comforting escape from the everyday.
Scalessa’s
Bringing a slice of South Philly to Delaware, Scalessa’s offers a delightful mix of Italian-American classics and hearty sandwiches. With its casual setting and flavorful offerings, this Wilmington favorite is a haven for comfort food enthusiasts.
Known for its famous meatballs and unique dishes like sausage, beans, and greens, Scalessa’s tantalizes taste buds with every bite. The fusion of traditional flavors and modern flair creates an unforgettable culinary journey. With a menu that speaks to the heart, Scalessa’s is more than a restaurant; it’s a destination for those seeking bold tastes and warm memories.
La Casa Pasta
Established in 1983, La Casa Pasta in Newark stands as a testament to the art of Italian cuisine. Specializing in seafood and house-made pasta, the restaurant offers a dining experience that elevates traditional flavors.
Dishes like Fusilli Santa Maria, with its creamy seafood sauce, highlight the commitment to quality ingredients. The elegant setting complements the rich menu, inviting guests to savor each bite. La Casa Pasta’s dedication to authenticity and taste has earned it a loyal following, making it a cherished culinary landmark in the community. It’s where elegance meets flavor, creating a harmonious blend of tastes.
Touch of Italy
Reflecting the owner’s Bronx heritage, Touch of Italy in Rehoboth Beach brings authentic Italian flavors to the coastal town. Using cherished family recipes, the restaurant serves classics like chicken Parmesan and various pasta dishes.
With an emphasis on quality ingredients and traditional cooking methods, Touch of Italy offers a genuine dining experience. The cozy ambiance and friendly service enhance the experience, making guests feel at home. It’s a place where history and flavor intertwine, creating a culinary masterpiece that pays homage to Italian traditions. Every dish is a nod to the past, yet a celebration of the present.
Frank & Louie’s Italian Specialties
Frank & Louie’s Italian Specialties, a family-owned deli in Rehoboth Beach, offers more than just food; it provides a taste of Italy. Known for its sandwiches, sauces, and baked goods, this casual spot is a treasure trove of culinary delights.
The commitment to quality and tradition shines through in every offering, with flavors that transport diners to the Italian countryside. Soon to transform into Pazzo Italiano, Frank & Louie’s promises to expand its offerings while maintaining beloved menu items. It’s a place where every bite tells a story, and every visit feels like a journey to Italy.
Casa Nonna
Inspired by the cherished recipes of grandmothers, Casa Nonna in Wilmington offers a menu that’s both classic and innovative. With a focus on comfort food and family connections, the restaurant serves dishes like lasagna and veal saltimbocca.
The warm ambiance invites diners to relax and enjoy, creating a sense of home away from home. Casa Nonna’s dedication to traditional flavors ensures a dining experience that resonates with warmth and nostalgia. It’s a place where every meal feels like a family gathering, and every dish tells a story of love and tradition.
Roma Italian Restaurant
Roma Italian Restaurant in Dover offers an inviting setting for those craving traditional Italian cuisine. The menu boasts a variety of pasta, seafood, and meat dishes, each crafted with authentic flavors.
The commitment to quality and service is evident in every dish, making Roma a popular choice for Italian dining in the area. The cozy atmosphere enhances the experience, offering a retreat from the everyday hustle. It’s a place where culinary excellence meets genuine hospitality, ensuring a memorable dining adventure. Every visit to Roma is a celebration of taste, tradition, and the art of Italian cooking.
Grotto Pizza
Founded in 1960, Grotto Pizza in Rehoboth Beach has become a regional icon, famous for its cheese pizzas with a unique swirl of sauce. Beyond pizza, the menu includes calzones, strombolis, and other Italian-American favorites.
The casual dining atmosphere makes Grotto Pizza a favorite among families and friends. With multiple locations across Delaware, it’s a convenient spot for those seeking quality and flavor. It’s a place where culinary innovation meets tradition, offering a delightful twist on classic Italian dishes. Every visit to Grotto Pizza promises a slice of joy and a taste of nostalgia.