Ohio is a haven for buckeye dessert enthusiasts. These delectable treats, inspired by the iconic buckeye nut, blend creamy peanut butter and rich chocolate.
From classic confections to innovative twists, Ohio’s offerings are irresistible.
Here’s a guide to eight must-visit spots across the state that serve buckeye desserts so delicious, families make them a staple of their travels.
Bake Me Happy (Columbus – Merion Village)
Bake Me Happy is a delightful spot in Merion Village, known for its gluten-free goodies. Imagine biting into a buckeye brownie with layers of creamy peanut butter and rich chocolate.
The bakery’s rustic charm adds to the experience, as families gather to savor these unique treats. These buckeye-inspired bars are not only delicious but a testament to creative baking.
Whether you’re gluten-sensitive or just love a good dessert, Bake Me Happy offers something special for every sweet tooth.
Anthony-Thomas Candy Company (Columbus)
In Columbus, the Anthony-Thomas Candy Company is a staple for traditional buckeyes. Picture smooth peanut butter centers enveloped in rich milk chocolate, crafted with care.
This family-owned business has been delighting locals and travelers alike with its classic confections. Stepping into the store, you’re greeted by a sweet aroma and a display of tempting treats.
It’s a must-visit for anyone seeking the authentic buckeye experience.
Schmidt’s Fudge Haus (Columbus – German Village)
Nestled in German Village, Schmidt’s Fudge Haus offers a creative take on buckeye desserts. Here, peanut-butter fudge and chocolate-coated confections tantalize taste buds.
The quaint shop exudes a warm atmosphere, drawing in dessert lovers with its enticing creations. Specialty pastries showcasing the beloved buckeye flavor profile are a highlight.
This spot is perfect for those seeking both tradition and innovation in their sweets.
Krema Nut Company (Grandview Heights/Columbus)
At Krema Nut Company, one of the oldest peanut-butter producers in the U.S., you’ll find hand-rolled buckeyes that are a true delight.
With a history steeped in tradition, this spot offers unique twists like ‘Buckeye Crunch’ for those who love added texture. The nutty aroma and vintage decor add to the charm, making it a memorable stop.
It’s a place where history and modern flavor meet.
Dorothy Lane Market (Dayton)
Dorothy Lane Market in Dayton is famed for its house-made buckeyes. With quality ingredients and a perfect peanut-butter-to-chocolate ratio, these desserts are a gourmet delight.
The elegant market setting enhances the experience, inviting families to explore and indulge. Rich flavors and meticulous craftsmanship define these buckeyes, making them a sought-after treat.
It’s a blend of sophistication and comfort in every bite.
The Buckeye Co. (Findlay)
The Buckeye Co. in Findlay is a haven for buckeye lovers. Specializing in a variety of treats, from classic to jumbo and seasonal variations, this shop caters to every palate.
The cozy atmosphere is welcoming, with shelves lined with delicious confections. Each buckeye is crafted with care, ensuring a memorable experience for visitors.
It’s a place where tradition meets creativity.
Butter Maid Bakery (Boardman)
Butter Maid Bakery in Boardman crafts large, handmade buckeyes that resonate with a rich, home-style taste. High-quality ingredients come together to create these delightful confections.
The bakery’s charm lies in its simplicity and commitment to quality, drawing in families and dessert enthusiasts alike.
Each bite offers a warm, comforting experience reminiscent of homemade treats.
The Buckeye Lady (Columbus)
The Buckeye Lady in Columbus is dedicated to buckeye innovation. With flavors ranging from cheesecake to red velvet, there’s something for every adventurous palate.
The shop’s vibrant atmosphere reflects its diverse offerings, inviting guests to explore new tastes.
It’s a destination for those who appreciate creativity in their desserts, pushing the boundaries of traditional buckeye flavors.